At a glance
| What you bought | Time to return |
|---|---|
| Store purchase — full refund | 30 days |
| Store purchase — merchandise credit | 60 days |
| Online order — full refund | 37 days |
| Online order — merchandise credit | 67 days |
How American Eagle compares
American Eagle's main return window is 30 days. That's longer than 2 of the 50 other stores we track, the same as 24, and shorter than 24. It's one of 21 stores with an extended 2026 holiday return window.
| Store | Main window | Bought Black Friday → last day |
|---|---|---|
| American Eagle | 30 days | Feb 1, 2027 🎄 |
| Abercrombie & Fitch | 30 days | Jan 31, 2027 🎄 |
| Hollister | 30 days | Jan 31, 2027 🎄 |
| Target | 90 days (120 w/ perk) | Feb 25, 2027 |
| Kohl's | 90 days (120 w/ perk) | Feb 25, 2027 |
| Old Navy | 30 days | Jan 15, 2027 🎄 |
Main window = each store's window for most purchases, from its own return policy. Black Friday = November 27, 2026; 🎄 = holiday extension.
The return window
- AE's 100% Happiness Promise: a full refund within 30 days of the purchase date, or merchandise credit within 60 days. Online purchases get an extra 7 days.
- Items must be unworn, unwashed and undamaged, with all labels and tags attached and hygienic liners in place for swimsuits and underwear.
- Online orders can't be returned until the whole order has shipped. Final sale items can't be returned or exchanged.
Where to return
- Store or online purchases can go back to any AE, Aerie, Offline or AE Factory store — free. A full refund needs proof of purchase (receipt, invoice, order history or order email).
- No proof of purchase? You can exchange for a different size.
- Online returns by mail cost $5 — free for Real Rewards Level 3 members, credit cardmembers, and Aerie bras, bralettes and swimsuits. In-store purchases can't be mailed back.
American Eagle holiday return policy (2026)
- Extended holiday returns (2026): with the original receipt or a gift receipt, anything bought online or in store on or after October 23, 2026 can be returned through February 1, 2027, or within 60 days of purchase, whichever is later.
- Purchases made through third-party apps go back through that app, under its own return rules.
- Bought on Black Friday, November 27, 2026 (store purchase — full refund): last day to return is Mon, Feb 1, 2027.
- Bought December 20, 2026 (store purchase — full refund): last day to return is Thu, Feb 18, 2027.
Holiday shopping? Every store's 2026 holiday return deadline →
American Eagle return policy FAQ
How long do you have to return something to American Eagle?
30 days for a refund, 60 for credit (+7 days online). AE's 100% Happiness Promise: a full refund within 30 days of the purchase date, or merchandise credit within 60 days. Online purchases get an extra 7 days.
What is American Eagle's return window for store purchase — merchandise credit?
60 days.
What is American Eagle's return window for online order — full refund?
37 days.
What is American Eagle's return window for online order — merchandise credit?
67 days.
What is American Eagle's holiday return policy for 2026?
American Eagle extends returns for the holidays: purchases made Oct 23 – Dec 31, 2026 can be returned until February 1, 2027. Bought on Black Friday, November 27, 2026 (store purchase — full refund): last day to return is Mon, Feb 1, 2027.
Checked against American Eagle's official return policy on October 7, 2026. Store policies change — confirm with American Eagle before you go.